A personal and historical examination of white Catholic anti-Blackness in the US told through 5 generations of one family, and a call for meaningful racial healing and justice within Catholicism
Excavating her Catholic family’s entanglements with race and racism from the time they immigrated to America to the present, Maureen O’Connell traces, by implication, how the larger Catholic population became white and why, despite the tenets of their faith, so many white Catholics have lukewarm commitments to racial justice.
O’Connell was raised by devoutly Catholic parents with a clear moral and civic guiding principle: those to whom much is given, much is expected. She became a theologian steeped in social ethics, engaged in critical race theory, and trained in the fundamentals of anti-racism. And still she found herself failing to see how her well-meaning actions affected the Black members of her congregations. It seemed that whenever she tried to undo the knots of racism, she only ended up getting more tangled in them.
Undoing the Knots weaves together narrative history, theology, and critical race theory to begin undoing these knots: to move away from doing good and giving back and toward dismantling the white Catholic identity and the economic and social structures it has erected and maintained.
“[The author’s] willingness to examine her actions while coming to the realization that, while her intentions have always been good, they do not address the problem, is incredibly refreshing . . . Though the material may be uncomfortable to digest, it is an absolutely necessary read to foster antiracism.”
—Booklist
"Recommended for readers interested in assimilation issues faced by Irish Catholic immigrants as well as the varied aspects of racism in the United States."
—Denise J. Stankovics, Library Journal
"O’Connell’s…revelation offers some hope to the reader: traditions are constantly evolving. Although Catholicism and anti-Blackness remain entangled, O’Connell believes that connection can be unwound."
—Emma McDonald, Commonweal Magazine
"[A] book that will challenge white Catholics to draw on the personal to see beyond it and confront systemic racism in the Church—possibly for the first time."
—Dr. Tia Noelle Pratt, curator of the #BlackCatholics Syllabus and assistant vice president for Mission Engagement and Strategic Initiatives, Villanova University
"Maureen O'Connell's important book. . . offers a model for how white Catholics can face up to our histories and find a way forward as people who pursue racial justice."
—John Gehring, National Catholic Reporter
"In unearthing the church’s troublesome history around racism through the lens of her own family, Maureen O’Connell invites us to join her on an intellectual, emotional, and spiritual journey that will give us the tools we need to show up for racial justice in our communities, especially our faith communities. A superb book by a gifted writer, a talented theologian, and a thoughtful observer of our contemporary world."
—James Martin, SJ, author of Jesus: A Pilgrimage
“Undoing the Knots is a bold, brave, courageous prayer and plea for us to create ‘a new earth.’ O’Connell’s incisive writing leads the reader into a soul excavation, one that peels back self-righteousness and makes you grapple with the destructive underlying scripts—from church doctrine to family conversations—that inform racism at its most personal level. This is a book that compels the reader to engage the conversation on race with head and heart, and to manifest that heart transformation through a commitment toward structural change within Catholic communities and the Church itself.”
—Rev. Natosha Reid Rice, founder of Fresh Rain for Life Ministries and Global Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion Officer for Habitat for Humanity International
“Maureen O’Connell’s Undoing the Knots is essential reading for this country’s conversation about whiteness and systemic racism from the angle of O’Connell&rrsquo;s faith tradition, Catholicism. At once personal and historical, narrative and analytical, O’Connell’s writing is vulnerable, searching, and open. Her desire to draw what is often a shameful history into the light is ultimately a hopeful project, and O’Connell is a worthy conversation partner on our journey to a more just union.”
—Donna Freitas, author of Consent: A Memoir of Unwanted Attention
“In unearthing the Church’s troublesome history around racism through the lens of her own family, Maureen O’Connell invites us to join her on an intellectual, emotional, and spiritual journey that will give us the tools we need to show up for racial justice in our communities, especially our faith communities. A superb book by a gifted writer, a talented theologian, and a thoughtful observer of our contemporary world.”
—James Martin, SJ, author of Jesus: A Pilgrimage
INTRODUCTION
Mattering: St. Vincent de Paul
CHAPTER ONE
Witnessing: St. James
CHAPTER TWO
Aligning: Christ’s Church
CHAPTER THREE
Grafting: St. Agnes
CHAPTER FOUR
Manufacturing: St. Charles Borromeo
CHAPTER FIVE
Maneuvering: St. Stephen’s
CHAPTER SIX
Defending: The Church of the Gesu
CHAPTER SEVEN
Homesteading: St. Francis of Assisi
CHAPTER EIGHT
Doubting: Catholic Higher Education
EPILOGUE
Undoing
Acknowledgments
Notes
Index
- “Buffalo shooting should be a wake-up call for white Catholics,” National Catholic Reporter, author quoted and book mentioned in piece
- “Entering the Chaos
Undoing the Knots,” Commonweal Magazine, review
- “22+ Books That Have Come Out So Far in 2022,” Patheos, included in new books roundup
- “Maureen O’Connell,” Wake Up with WURD/Hosted by Solomon Jones, live interview
- “My family’s unsettling St. Patrick’s Day memories are an anti-racist opportunity,” MSNBC/Think, op-ed
- “La Salle professor explores ‘undoing the knots’ of Catholic anti-Blackness through her own family history,” Philadelphia Inquirer, Q&A
- “Undoing the Knots: Conversation with Maureen O’Connell, PhD,” Potstirrer Podcast, podcast interview
- “Maureen H. O’Connell – Undoing the Knots: Five Generations of American Catholic Anti-Blackness,” Public Theologian, podcast interview
- “What one Irish Catholic family gained (and lost) from white privilege,” The Gloria Purvis Podcast, podcast interview
- “Dr. Maureen O’Connell,” The Vicars’ Crossing, podcast interview
- “Buzz Books Fall/Winter Preview: Nonfiction Part 2,” Publishers Marketplace, book included in Buzz Books Fall/Winter nonfiction preview